Why intrinsic motivation is not always the best choice

Share this article with others:

Motivation is the driving force behind our actions. However, not every type of motivation leads to optimal results in every situation. Particularly in the discussion about intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, it is often assumed that intrinsic motivation is desirable per se. But this is a fallacy. It is much more important to adapt the type of motivation to the type of task.

High performance through intrinsic motivation

An intrinsically motivated person is highly committed. They take pleasure in the activity itself and develop enormous performance when they can identify with a task. But this is precisely where the challenge lies: if an organization or company fails to provide an appropriate environment for this motivation, frustration arises. A highly motivated person who is trapped in an environment with rigid structures and monotonous tasks will not be able to unleash their energy. Instead, they will experience demotivation and dissatisfaction.

This means that intrinsic motivation must not only be encouraged, but also utilized. To do this, it is essential to analyze the type of activity in detail and understand which type of motivation is most effective in the specific situation.

When is extrinsic motivation more suitable?

There are tasks where extrinsic motivation is much more efficient. For example, if a task requires a high degree of standardization, specifies clear processes and leaves little scope for individual design, then intrinsic motivation can come to nothing. In this case, it is primarily about achieving a predetermined goal, not about developing personal strengths or creative potential.

Intrinsische Motivation oder extrinsische Motivation
Intrinsic motivation or extrinsic motivation

In such scenarios, extrinsic incentives are more effective. Clear targets, reward systems and structures that support a standardized approach help to achieve results efficiently and reliably. However, this does not mean that extrinsic motivation is more sustainable in the long term, but that it is simply more appropriate in certain contexts.

Scientific principles and practical implications

The Self-Determination Theory (Deci & Ryan) has shown that people have three central psychological needs: Autonomy, competence and social connectedness. These needs promote intrinsic motivation. If they are lacking in a working environment, intrinsic motivation cannot develop or be maintained.

Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi's flow theory supports this insight: people experience flow when their skills are optimally aligned with the challenge of the task. However, if there is no opportunity to use these skills in a meaningful way, intrinsic motivation fizzles out. Dan Pink also pointed this out in his well-known TED Talk: Intrinsic motivation is only conducive to performance if autonomy, mastery (experience of competence) and purpose (impact) are present.

The right approach: a systematic audit

The central consequence of these findings is that a given situation must first be analyzed in detail before a decision on a motivation strategy can be made. A structured audit helps to evaluate the framework conditions of a task and to understand which type of motivation should be promoted.

Such an audit should answer the following questions:

  • What degrees of freedom does the task offer?
  • Is the goal predetermined (standardization) or is the path the actual goal (innovation and service)?
  • Does the task require creativity and individual performance or above all discipline and compliance with the rules?

To carry out this analysis efficiently and with consistent quality, I have developed the Pathfinder System. It offers a clear procedure and framework that companies and organizations can use to consciously decide which type of motivation is best suited to a particular situation. The result is a systematic and final classification of the situation in the Behavioral Solution Matrix, which allows the right choice of motivational strategy to be derived from a variety of possible solutions.

It is therefore not enough to always rely solely on intrinsic motivation because it is more sustainable in the long term. In certain situations, extrinsic motivation is simply more appropriate. In order to allow optimal performance development, the task must first be analyzed in detail and then the appropriate motivation strategy selected.

Don’t Stop Here

More To Explore

Smart Fuzzy goals

SMART goals are not the future

Warum unscharfe Ziele der wahre Schlüssel zur Innovation in einer AI-Welt sind Seit Jahren sind SMART Ziele – spezifische, messbare, erreichbare, relevante und zeitgebundene Ziele

en_USEnglish

Kontakt & Booking

Sie haben eine Vortrags- oder Workshopanfrage?

Rufen Sie gerne an oder schreiben Sie uns.

WordPress Cookie Plugin by Real Cookie Banner